< Previous by Date Date Index Next by Date >
< Previous in Thread Thread Index  

Re: [reSIProcate] Can sip ACK be used for Register response



On 27-Apr-2007, at 14:42 , Yuan, Frank wrote:

phone.  So I wonder if SIP ACK could be used for Register response since LINKSYS SIPURA phone is very popular and could not make this kind of silly mistake.


I have to admit that it is surprising to see this, but it is NOT legal. The stack should discard the ACK. I've seen the odd load in the last 6 years from reputable companies that make very silly and strange mistakes - they are typically correctly quickly.

I agree with Robert - if at all possible, isolate this UA to confirm that NOTHING else (b2bua, alg, etc) is in the signaling path and creating the trace you are seeing. If you can do this, then in my opinion, you have confirmed a bug in the Linksys PAP2 UA firmware.

Best of luck,

Alan Hawrylyshen

a l a n a t p o l y p h a s e d o t c a