< Previous by Date Date Index Next by Date >
< Previous in Thread Thread Index Next in Thread >

Re: [reSIProcate] auth info in BYE same as INVITE 403 / advancedAuthenticateRequest() passes millsecond expires, but compares seconds


On 3/3/07, Justin Matthews <jmatthewsr@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
If DUM challenges an INVITE and then successfully authenticates a call and
the UA then sends DUM a BYE and copies the auth info from the original
INVITE, a 403 is returned because the Method portion of the request-uri is
used in calculating A2 and the Method is now BYE and originally was INVITE.

Can you clarify which user agent you are talking about in this case?

T1: UA1  sends INVITE to UA2 (dum)
T2: UA2 challenges with 407
T3: UA1 resend INVITE to UA2 with credentials
...
T4: UA1 sends BYE to UA2 (dum) copying credentials from INVITE
T5: UA2 sends 403

Is this the behavior you are seeing? In this case UA2 should send a
407 in T5 if the method is used to compute the nonce in T2.

Jason




Is this behavior by the UA sending the BYE completely against the spec(s),
or should DUM be able to allow my app to decide whether to accept this kind
of behavior?

  Also, the call to advancedAuthenticateRequest in ServerAuthManager.cxx
passes 3000 as a hard-coded expiration for the nonce value, is this meant to
be 3 seconds?  The comparison on nonce expiration values is done in seconds
in advancedAuthenticateRequest.  On a side note, how was the value of the
expiration interval decided?




Thanks,



Justin




_______________________________________________
resiprocate-devel mailing list
resiprocate-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://list.resiprocate.org/mailman/listinfo/resiprocate-devel